IP Journal of Otorhinolaryngology and Allied Science

Print ISSN: 2582-4147

Online ISSN: 2582-421X

CODEN : IJOABK

IP Journal of Otorhinolaryngology and Allied Science (JOAS) open access, peer-reviewed quarterly journal publishing since 2018 and is published under the Khyati Education and Research Foundation (KERF), is registered as a non-profit society (under the society registration act, 1860), Government of India with the vision of various accredited vocational courses in healthcare, education, paramedical, yoga, publication, teaching and research activity, with the aim of faster and better dissemination more...


  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article statistics

Viewed: 99

PDF Downloaded: 51

Kr Gupta and Gupta: The study of cases of hoarseness of voice of north India region


Introduction

In Medical Science, Hoarseness is the term used to describe a change in normal quality of voice of a patient which is rough or harsh, lower in pitch and more or less discordant.1 Hoarseness of voice is one of common symptom in otolaryngological practice and is invariably the earlier manifestation of laryngeal involvement directly or indirectly by disease.

Jackson and Jackson (1930) observed that hoarseness is the most important symptom of laryngeal disease and it will not manifest when the cords and the motor mechanism are entirely free from disease.2 However, he re-emphasized that hoarseness is not a disease in itself, but rather a symptom of disease or disturbance in the larynx or along the course of the laryngeal motor nerve. It is often the first and only signal of serious local or systemic disease (Von Leden, 1958).3

Depends on duration of illness, hoarseness can be divided into acute or chronic condition. The acute onset is more common and mainly caused by inflammation (acute laryngitis) chronic sinusitis acid reflux disease, excessive alcohol use, smoking and over use or misuse of voice whereas other cause may be, laryngeal trauma or thyroid surgery and systemic disease.4

The chronic onset is mainly caused by chronic laryngitis vocal nodule, polyp, laryngeal papillomatosis, tumour of vocal cord, vocal fold haemorrhage, functional dysphonia, smoking, vocal abuse, laryngopharyngeal reflux disease, post nasal drip, vocal abuse, neoplasm of thyroid, oesophagus, lung, chronic granulomatous disease like tuberculosis or systemic disease like diabetes mellitus.5 The complaints of hoarseness of long duration may suggest serious disease, so it should not be ignored and to be examined thoroughly for making proper differential diagnosis.6

Hoarseness of voice should be diagnosed in a patient with altered voice quality and pitch and prompt evaluation is needed to detect specific etiological factor and its pathology. The disease ranges from benign to the most malignant manifestation7 and therefore a various parameter was considered under present study. The aim of our study is to analyse clinical profile, assess different etiological factors and to find out common precipitating factors leading to hoarseness of voice.

Material and Methods

The retrospective study was carried out at Department of ENT, Government Medical College & Super facility Hospital and data were collected from June 2017 to May 2019 of a period of two years durations. The proforma and master chart were designed based on objective of the study. As per proforma, detailed history of disease, examinations methods and finding, clinical features and differential diagnoses were recorded from medical record section of the college, OPD centre of hospital and pathological reports and imaging reports were collected from pathology and radiology department of the institution for complete study.

Table 1

Age & sex wise distribution

Age Group

Male (%)

Female (%)

Total

11-20

13 (7.87%)

08 (9.09%)

21(8.30%)

21-30

28 (16.96%)

24 (27.27%)

52 (20.55%)

31-40

27(16.36%)

28 (31.81%)

55 (21.73%)

41-50

30 (18.18%)

11(12.50%)

41(16.20.%)

51-60

44 (26.66%)

12(13.63%)

56 (22.13%)

>60

23 (13.93%)

05 (5.68%)

28 (11.06%)

Total

165 (65.21%)

88 (34.78%)

253 (100%)

Table 2

Distribution of profession in hoarseness of voice patients

Profession

Male (%)

Female (%)

Total (%)

Sportsman

02 (1.21%)

-

02 (0.79%)

Singer

09 (5.45%)

06 (6.81%)

15 (5.92%)

Policeman

04 (2.42%)

01(1.13%)

05 (1.97%)

Teacher

23 (13.93%)

11(12.50%)

34 (13.43%)

Politician

11(6.66%)

02 (2.27%)

13 (5.13%)

Labour

40 (24.24%)

07 (7.95%)

47 (18.57%)

Housewife

-

50 (56.81%)

50 (19.76%)

Farmer

47 (28.48%)

02 (2.27%)

49 (19.36%)

Others

29 (17.57%)

09 (10.22%)

38 ((15.01))

Total

165

88

253

Table 3

Duration of hoarseness in patients of present study

Duration

No of Cases (%)

<7 days

04 (1.58%)

3 months-6 months

56 (22.13%)

6 months-12 months

167(66%)

> 12 months

26 (10.27%)

Total

253

Table 4

Showing predisposing factors of hoarseness of voice along with sex wise distribution

Habits

Male

Female

Total

Functional

06 (3.63%)

07 (7.95%)

13 (5.13%)

Smoking

65 (39.39%)

21(23.86%)

86 (33.99%)

Alcohol

34 (20.60%)

06 (6.81%)

40 (15.81%)

Tobacco components

53 (20.94%)

44 (50%)

97 (38.33%)

Vocal Abuse

02 (1.21%)

04 (4.54%)

06 (2.37%)

No Habits

05 (3.03%)

06 (6.81%)

11 (4.34%)

Total

165

88

253

Table 5

Showing different clinical conditions associated with hoarseness of voice.

Clinical Condition

Male

Female

Total

Acute Laryngitis

53 (32.12%)

37 (42.04%)

90 (35.57%)

Chronic Laryngitis

44 (26.66%)

24 (27.27%)

68 (26.87%)

Vocal Card Palsy

13 (7.87%)

07 (7.95%)

20 (22.72%)

Vocal Cord Nodules

18 (10.90%)

05 (5.68%)

23 (9.09%)

Vocal Cord Polyp

09 (5.45%)

04 (4.54%)

13 (5.13%)

Vocal Cord Cyst

05 (3.03%)

02 (2.27%)

07 (2.76%)

Malignancy

19 (11.51%)

07(7.95%)

26 (10.27%)

Trauma

04 (2.42%)

02 (2.27%)

06 (2.37)

Total

165

88

253

Observation and Results

A total of 34500 patients visited OPD of Otolaryngology department from June 2017 to May2019. Out of these,253 cases presented with complaint of change in voice (Hoarseness). The incidence of hoarseness among total OPD patient was 0.73%.

Among 253 cases, 165 (65.21%) were male and 88 (34.78%) were female. Male predominance was observed with Male: female ratio of 1.87:1 in this study.

Majority of patients (22.13%) were reported in 51-60 years age group followed by 31-40 years age group (21.73%). least cases were reported in 11-20 years age group. Male patients showed higher percentage (26.66%) in 51-60 years age group and female patient showed higher percentage (31.81%) in 31-40 years age group.

Largest group of patients were housewives (19.76%), then farmer (19.36%%) and labour (18.57%). Rest was teacher (13.43%), singer (5.92%) politician (5.13%), policeman (1.97%) and sportsman (0.79%). In male largest group were farmer (28.48%), labour (24.24%) then teacher (13.93%). In female, largest group was of housewives (56.81%), teacher (12.50%) and then singer (6.81%).

Duration of hoarseness was taken from 7 days to more than 12 months. Most of presenting complaint (66%) were noticed in 6 months - 12 months duration than in 22.13% cases in 3months – 6 months duration and in 10.27% cases hoarseness has been reported with history of more than 12 months period

Many predisposing factors were noted like tobacco chewing, smoking, alcohol drinking. Tobacco chewing (38.33%), smoking (33.99%) and alcohol consumption (15.81%) were most common predisposing factors in descending order. Functional disorder was reported in (5.13%) cases and vocal abuse in 2.37% cases.

In different clinical conditions, hoarseness of voice was reported. Acute and chronic laryngitis were reported in 35.57% and 26.87% cases respectively. Malignancy was reported in 10.27% cases, vocal cord palsy in 22.22% cases, Vocal cord nodule in 9.09% cases and vocal cord polyp in 4.74% cases.

Figure 1

Duration of hoarseness in patients of present study

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/ea77f2c9-c644-4f01-90f9-937593f572f4/image/e5d306d8-6fb7-4e7b-b78b-0a0145b9ecfc-uimage.png

Figure 2

Duration of hoarseness in patients of present study

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/ea77f2c9-c644-4f01-90f9-937593f572f4/image/e2f8f410-32f4-42db-9cf7-39383176667a-uimage.png

Discussion

In our study Male: Female Radio of 1.87:1 with male predominance was observed. Our finding is exactly in confirmation with that of others studies which were done in India and it also showed male predominance.

Herrington-Hall et al (1988) stated that taking age group as variable, it is clear that laryngeal pathologies occur most frequently in the older age group because infectious condition like acute and chronic laryngitis, carcinoma and vocal fold paralysis being the most commonly found causes of vocal dysfunction in the elderly.7 Females presented with laryngeal pathologies at a slightly younger age. In our study in 31.81% female cases, hoarseness of voice was reported in 31-40 years age group and in 26.66% male cases, hoarseness was reported in 51–60-year age group

Duration of hoarseness ranged from 7 days to more than 12 months were taken under our study and in maximum patients, manifestation of a hoarseness of voice was reported in 6 months -12 months duration.

Fritzell (1996) and Titze et al (1997) reported that professionals with the highest risk of having voice problems are singers, teachers, lawyers, salespersons, and health professionals. An important point is that a professional voice user will seek medical help only if he or she is aware of its importance among other things. 8 Smith et al. (1997) concluded that teaching was a high-risk occupation for voice disorders with the possibility of significant work-related consequences Clark A Rosen (2000) proposed classification and nomenclature, and divided voice disorder into four major categories.9

  1. Non-Organic Voice Disorder (Functional): It has a common finding of dysphonia associated with normal vocal fold morphology and motion. It includes muscle tension dysphonia, conversion dysphonia, psychogenic dysphonia and functional dysphonia.

  2. Organic Voice Disorders: It involve actual pathological changes to larynx in general and vocal fold in specific and includes vocal nodules, polyps, cysts,edema, granuloma, leucoplakia, carcinoma of vocal fold, etc.

  3. Movement Disorder: It involves abnormal movement of larynx and caused by abnormalities in muscle control. Common disorders within this category are unilateral vocal fold paralysis, spasmodic dysphonia, etc.

  4. Systemic Disease: It affect the voice production system. Often systemic diseases have adverse effects on the function of the vocal production tracts and results in a voice change, e.g. reflux laryngitis, infections of larynx and neurological diseases like Parkinson’s disease and hormonal disease like Hypothyroidism.

Batra et al (2004) accounted that functional voice disorders are caused by insufficient or improper use of vocal mechanism without any pathological and neurological disorders and it includes vocal fatigue, muscle tension, dysphonia, aphonia, phonotrauma and falsetto.10

Hoarseness is most frequently noticed in patient with different psychological disorders. The voice can be described as an emotional part of each person. Sundberg (1987) described that articulatory and laryngeal structures, and respiratory muscle activity patterns change during stress, anger and bipolar disorder.

In patient with hoarseness of voice and history of tobacco use may have laryngeal malignancy and alcohol use increases the risk of malignancy in smokers.

Advice of vocal hygiene, medicine, vocal conservation should be recommended along with speech therapy and psychotherapy.[11] In present study most of the patients were referred for speech therapy and psychotherapy along with vocal conservation and maintenance of vocal hygiene.

Conclusion

The incidence of hoarseness was 0.73% among total OPD and. M:F ratio was 1.87:1 with male predominance. Hoarseness of voice is just a symptom with a very diverse etiological factor. The etiological data varies in different geographical location, so every case should be carefully and thoroughly evaluated and examined to know the early diagnosis of underlying pathology for prevention and accurate management of patient.

Middle aged and elderly patients presenting with hoarseness of voice of more than six months duration along with habits of smoking and chewing tobacco preparations must be thoroughly examined and malignancy condition should be excluded out. The voice can be restored to near normal with appropriate treatment, follow-up at fixed interval must be done in most of the benign and malignancy conditions.

Source of Funding

None.

Conflict of Interest

None.

References

1 

J Jackson L Jackson Diseases of the Nose, Throat and Ear. Philadelphia: WB Saunders1959https://www.amazon.com/Diseases-Nose-Throat-Chevalier-Jackson/dp/B00NMO5SIU

2 

V Leden The Clinical Significance of Hoarseness and Related Voice DisordersJ Lancet195878503

3 

J A Koufman G Isaacson The spectrum of vocal dysfunctionOtolaryngol Clin North AM19912459858

4 

S Baitha R M Raizada K Singh A K Puttewar M P Chaturvedi Clinical profile of hoarseness of voiceClinical profile of Hoarsens of voice200254114810.1007/BF02910998

5 

S P Khavasi Aetiopathological Study of Hoarseness of Voice. A thesis submitted for Mater of Surgery (Otorhinolaryngology) Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences1985

6 

N Parik Aetiology study of 100 cases of hoarseness of Voice.Indian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg199143713

7 

B L Herrington-Hall L Lee J C Stemple K R Niemi M M McHone Description of Laryngeal Pathologies by Age, Sex, and Occupation in a Treatment-Seeking SampleJ Speech Hear Dis1988531576410.1044/jshd.5301.57

8 

V Wolfe D Martina Acoustic correlation of Dysphonia: types and severityJ Commun Dis19973054031610.1016/S0021-9924(96)00112-8

9 

C A Rosen R E Arffa Voice Disorder classificationJ Voice20122644625

10 

K Batra G Motwani P C Sagar Functional voice disorders and their occurrence in 100 patients of hoarseness as seen on fibreoptic laryngoscopyIndian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg200456291510.1007/BF02974305



jats-html.xsl

© This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.


Article type

Original Article


Article page

50-53


Authors Details

Mahendra Kr Gupta, Ravi Gupta


Article History

Received : 08-04-2021

Accepted : 08-05-2021

Available online : 04-08-2021


Article Metrics


View Article As

 


Downlaod Files

   








Wiki in hindi